Word and Rhyme

Fiction Poetry Life

Go West, Young Woman: Do the Restless Live Richer Lives?

Elizabeth Bishop’s wonderful poem “Letter to N.Y.” is one of my all-time favorites. The narrator starts with…

In your next letter I wish you’d say
where you are going and what you are doing;
how are the plays and after the plays
what other pleasures you’re pursuing:

I imagine that the narrator and the one she’s sending the letter to are hometown friends and that the narrator may never leave their place of birth. The best she can hope for, some might think, is to experience the big city vicariously through her friend.

There Are Two Kinds of People in the World…

The world is full of people who are known as the restless kind. image_b_for_letter_to_ny_320x213They can’t stay put anywhere for too long. They often uproot their lives and move from city to city and they travel to new places all the time. 

Then there are the homebodies. Vacations are always staycations, whether they have the money to travel or not. They would never dream of moving away from the city or town they were born and raised in.

What if You Don’t Want to See the World?

In December of 2008, the Pew Research Center released a social and demographic trends report called American Mobility: Who Moves? Who Stays Put? Where’s Home?.  The study found that 37% of Americans have never left their hometowns and 57% have never lived outside their current home state.

If Bishop’s narrator never leaves her hometown, she will have experiences that her friend with the wanderlust will never have. Although conventional wisdom says that those who stay are missing out on life, not ever moving from the place you were born gives you a perspective you can’t get when you go out and see the world.

Staying put and getting to know one place so well that it becomes part of you provides a singular insight into life.

All of this made me think of the well-known T.S. Eliot quote: “We shall not cease from exploration, and the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we started and know the place for the first time.” I used to take this quote literally, thinking you have to physically leave and return to a place to truly know it.

But it can be interpreted another way. Those who never physically leave home can explore other places in books and film and in the life experiences of those they know well. Exploring the cultural and social differences of other people and places, regardless of how we go about it, helps us reflect on our own situation and gives us an idea of where and how we fit into the world.

The Tradeoff

When I was younger, I had an affinity for the restless kind and did a fair imitation of one. The excitement and pleasure of moving to a new city and getting to know the streets, the people, the cafes and the museums was too great to resist. I believed it was the best way to get an education away from the classrooms and lecture halls. And I wondered, why would anyone not want to leave the home of their childhood and explore the country or the world beyond?

On reflection, I think that’s a myopic way to view things.

I’m originally from Cleveland. Growing up, I liked my hometown, but once I was away I looked down on it. I thought it was too conventional, too boring, lacked creative energy. Throughout my twenties and thirties, I lived in some great American cities, all with their own charms. But you know what? Not one of them compares to my Cleveland, the home of rock and roll. As the years go by my affection for that old steel mill town grows and grows.

My perspective on my hometown has shifted through the years, and, no doubt, has been enriched by my travels. Moving away gave me the chance to compare and contrast, to see how it holds up against other places. So I have no regrets, but I’ll also never know what life would be like if I’d stayed. Both I and Cleveland change from decade to decade. What if we had grown and changed together?

Leaving home means losing connections. Relationships suffer. Homesickness can crop up at the most inconvenient times. On the Thought Catalog blog, Chelsea Fagan writes this about those who move away: “Returning to your hometown will, from now on, have a quality of nostalgia to it that prevents you from fully embracing the moment.” This is so beautifully and accurately put, I wish I’d written it myself. It’s what Thomas Wolfe meant when he said “you can’t go home again.” Certainly, in leaving, there’s also loss.

Always Be Curious

The key to experiencing life is not a U-Haul truck, its curiosity.

Bishop ends “Letter to N.Y.” with

—Wheat, not oats, dear. I’m afraid
if it’s wheat it’s none of your sowing,
nevertheless I’d like to know
what you are doing and where you are going. 

In this moment, the narrator seems to have a certain wisdom that comes from observing others, namely her friend. She tells her friend that she’s too innocent to sow wild oats, what she’s actually doing there in New York City is sowing wheat.

Those of us who left our hometowns shouldn’t think our life experiences are any richer than those who chose to stay. After all, you can travel the world without your mind ever expanding. On the other hand, you can get to know all types of people by getting to know a few people very well. That’s because, regardless of culture or geographic location, what’s common to all humans is the desire to love and be loved, the capacity to feel pain and loss and the need for community, to belong to something.

The one thing that’s common to a fortunate few is a grand curiosity about our existence and what makes people tick. We can fulfill this curiosity by examining life either in cities or towns thousands of miles from where we grew up or right in our own back yard.

Literature Cited: Letter to N.Y.
Author: Elizabeth Bishop

photo credit: kern.justin via photopin

I’d love to hear your story. Did you leave your hometown or have you always lived in the place of your birth? Do you think a person has to leave their hometown to truly experience life?


3 comments on “Go West, Young Woman: Do the Restless Live Richer Lives?

  1. audrey
    January 28, 2014

    I did leave my hometown and for years never thought I would want to grow old there. In my senior years I often wonder what would my life had been like if I had stayed and simply became enriched by the environment that I was born to. But I do believe that whether you stay or not

  2. audrey
    January 28, 2014

    To finish the reply above.

    But I do believe that whether you stay or not, what is important is do you feel your life has a purpose and did you use some of the gift(s) that you were born with.

    • Johanna Chambers
      February 2, 2014

      Yes, I think that most people who leave their hometown and don’t return to live there again wonder how their life would have turned out if they’d stayed. Leaving or staying are equally valuable experiences, especially if, as you say, your life has a purpose.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on January 27, 2014 by in Classic Literature, Poetry and tagged , , , , .
January 2014
« Dec   Feb »
%d bloggers like this: